Market Commentary Q3 2018

By: Matt Garrott

The S&P 500 is up 10% year to date.  Does it feel like it?  While the US stock market is having a strong year and the economy flexes its muscles, long-term investors may be feeling left behind.  Why?  Domestic stocks are up double digits, but a portfolio of 60% stocks / 40% bonds is only up 5.6%.  A more diverse portfolio might only be up 3%.  Bonds are flat or slightly down on the year and international stocks are down and being stomped by the strong dollar.  Diversification that saved investors from the worst of the financial crisis now weighs on performance.

Why Invest Internationally At All?

Despite the short-term (now intermediate-term, really) underperformance of international stocks, consider:

  • The United States makes up about half of the market capitalization of the equities in the MSCI All Country World Index and about a third of the global bond market.
  • Access to international stocks and bonds is getting easier and cheaper.
  • The global opportunity set is growing as more countries open themselves to foreign investors (China A shares, Saudi Arabia) in both equity and bond markets.
  • The strong US Dollar has been a headwind for both developed and emerging market equities.
  • Foreign Central Banks are still holding rates incredibly low as they lag behind the US in recovering from the financial crisis.
  • Valuations for developed and emerging markets are below their 25-year average while US valuations are higher than their average.

Continue Reading

Get Your M&Ms Sorted Sooner Rather Than Later

By: Matt Garrott

The Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin, recently passed away with an $80 million estate… and no will.  The news follows in the footsteps of other celebrities (Prince comes to mind) who never found the time to complete their financial plan.  Most of our clients aren’t cashing royalty checks, but the lesson is still the same.  In the financial planning world, investing steals the spotlight, but the other aspects of financial planning are what make the show run smoothly.

Continue Reading

A Bold Prediction

By: Matt Garrott

I have a bold prediction to make.  Yes, I know I talk all time about how Fairway isn’t in the prediction business and that basing any long-term financial decision on a forward-looking prediction is a fool’s game, but I’m going to do it anyway:

I predict that the 10-year return on the S&P 500 is going to rise substantially in the next several quarters.  Wow, that sounds bold…is Matt really saying that he thinks the market is going to rise big-time the rest of this year?  Of course I’m not saying that!  My honest answer is I have no idea what the market will do in the next few quarters.

Continue Reading

Portfolio Sunscreen

By: Matt Garrott

It’s July and in Cleveland the sun is finally out.  The summer sun brings with it the potential for sunburn.  Sunscreen is essential to avoid the pain and potential long-term damage from getting burned, but when it works we don’t really notice its positive effect.  Having bonds in a portfolio Continue Reading

Chasing Outperformance


By: Matt Garrott

One of my favorite investment reads is The Route to Performance by Oaktree Capital’s Howard Marks.  Marks starts by disputing the argument that more risk means more return, “If you want to be in the top 5% of money managers, you have to be willing to be in the bottom 5%, too.”  Instead of outperformance, this philosophy can lead to a “long-term record which is characterized by volatility and mediocrity.”  He then recalled a meeting he had with a pension plan director:

“We have never had a year below the 47th percentile over that period or, until 1990, above the 27th percentile.  As a result, we are in the fourth percentile for the fourteen year period as a whole.”

Instead of taking big risks, the pension plan director aimed for consistent performance, resulting in stellar long-term performance as peers self-destructed.

The Howard Marks note was written in 1990, but is still relevant today.  The SPIVA Persistence Scorecard further debunks the idea of an investment strategy placing in the top 10 (or even 50!) percent of its peer group every year.  Investment manager selection isn’t about picking what fund will outperform in a calendar year, it’s about finding consistent performance.  For most asset classes, that means buying the index. 

Fairway Scorecard 5-31-2018

This Will End Badly

By: Matt Garrott

It’s clear that 2018 will not be a repeat of 2017.  Low volatility, a steady march up and to the right, and a general disregard for headline risk were last year’s calling cards.  2018 seems jittery by comparison, but is actually a more normal market.  Historically, drawdowns have been slower and deeper, but maybe this year’s sharp drops and rebounds Continue Reading

Markets in “Turmoil”

By: Matt Garrott

The stock market fell back to earth at the end of February as CNBC trotted out its ‘Markets in Turmoil’ chyron.  For all its gyrations, as of the end of February the S&P 500 was up about 1% for the year – hardly turmoil territory.  Continue Reading

Investors’ Biggest Concern Right Now Should Be Their Own Behavior

By: Mark Weiskind

The S&P 500 was up 5.7% in January, after a 20%+ year in 2017.  But instead of enjoying this pleasant surprise, everyone seemed to be wondering if things were going too well.  Market volatility is historically low.  When will it snap back?  The Fed is raising rates.  What if this shocks the markets?  Political volatility is everywhere. Won’t this volatility eventually bleed into the markets?  Continue Reading

Market Commentary: Year-End 2017

By: Matt Garrott

What Happened in 2017

 Experts predicted that 2017 would be a difficult year for investors.  Looking back, they are now calling it an easy year.  All investors had to do was stay invested, but how ‘easy’ was that?  Half of a year-end Barrons roundtable of investment experts predicted S&P 500 returns of 5% or less.  News headlines were dominated by tragedy (multiple natural disasters) and political uncertainty.

Continue Reading

Now What?

By: Matt Garrott

Everything went according to plan.  Now what?  After a lifetime of saving, it can be difficult to justify spending on things that we once considered frivolous.

Meir Statman recently wrote a paper for the Financial Planning Association titled “Are Your Clients Not Spending Enough in Retirement?” that outlines an interesting conundrum for many retirees.  Diligent savers sometimes find it difficult to switch from the wealth accumulation phase of life to the spending phase.  The widely accepted narrative that there is a retirement crisis in the United States influences these savers to prioritize penny-pinching over their own happiness.  Statman calls this “self-induced poverty”.

We’re not suggesting that you should go out and buy a solid gold toilet, but it is important not to lose track of the purpose of your personal wealth accumulation.  If it was for a comfortable retirement, are you actively allocating to that?  A financial plan is not necessarily a function to maximize wealth.  It should also consider how you aim to enjoy that wealth through lifestyle, legacy, and peace of mind.

Fairway Scorecard 11-30-2017